Chiming In (the Agony and the Ecstasy)
Jörg Heiser
Elín Jakobsdóttir’s and Mark Sadler’s joint exhibition begins with modest-sized mutual head portraits and an audio piece. Sadler’s pencil drawing of Jakobsdóttir is elegant and decisive, raised eyebrow like a single stroke, only the lips slightly coloured with a faint apricot hue. Jakobsdóttir’s in turn feels almost like a stone sculpture, chiselled, precise, brownish and dense. Again, a slightly skeptically raised eyebrow (both works 1997). Same not same but different.
As if someone had left the radio on, tuned to a talk station, we hear a warm baritone voice (that of architect Roger Bundschuh, friend and sometimes collaborator) telling the story of a studio visit. Written by Sadler, the text depicts an awkward but fascinating encounter: Gohar, a proud and tall sculptor, presents her work to Losf, a shaken and embarrassed city planner. He has come in view of a possible architectural commission, but “the boat of personal anxiety that had brought him so quickly in to the room had run aground on strange territory”. His anxiety must have something to do with the challenges of aesthetic judgment (“he was quite lost”), possibly misogynist envy (a failed “demolition strategy”), but also with a mixture of depression and romanticism (“He had been caught out by the sculpture. How dare it fit so well the stump inside his soul”). The scene is beautifully set for the entanglements that permeate throughout the ensuing exhibition: that of identifying and transcending identity, intimacy and publicity, art and the conditions of its making.
Yes, Jakobsdóttir and Sadler are a long-time couple – but not in the sense of a duo continuously, collaboratively making joint work (also, neither of them is the de facto manager or assistant of the other). That said, they do sometimes collaborate. And their respective works do sometimes resonate, if not overlap in focus and form, but also often diverge pronouncedly from each other. Since the 1980s writer and theorist Klaus Theweleit has analysed extensively the way the idea of the “muse” effectively produced a relationship of abuse (including sexual), in which the male part of the couple constellation used the other as “mediale Frau” (mediating woman) to foster and maintain their production, sometimes to the point of plagiarizing the female partner’s work or even passing it off as their own. And that did include, as Theweleit dissected, supposedly egalitarian-thinking artists like Bertolt Brecht. It wasn’t until 1960s and constellations like Jean Tinguely/Nikki de Saint Phalle or John Lennon/Yoko Ono that a “true” sense of equality at eye level became possible, also as what Theweleit calls Produktionssexualität (“production sexuality”), which is the libidinal investment the artists in such a constellation have put into their respective work to create something substantial – which pronouncedly does not mean they would have to bend work, sex and love into a utopian continuum of work/sex/love, leading in most cases to dystopian collapse (see Otto Muehl commune etc.). In that respect, Jakobsdóttir/Sadler are as much children of the 1960s aesthetic and political revolution as much as they, post-punk-style, reflect on the darker shadows in its wake.
To interpret Jakobsdóttir’s paintings, objects and silent films predominantly, or even only, in relation to Sadler’s would be fundamentally false (and, of course, vice versa). Clearly hers for example is a slightly Louise-Bourgeois-esque, biting, dark sense of humour present in Eternal Unrest Pram Coffin (both as drawing and real-life object), which bluntly combines the shapes of pram and coffin into one, thus resembling the pinball machine of life and death, with empty elongated clothes sticking out of the front end like shed skin. In numerous of her recent large paintings, confidently but sketchily outlined naked bodies (like Renaissance studies fused with Bruce Nauman neons) sit awkwardly, sleep uncomfortably, fall Ikarus-like, or spiral machine-like, into voluptuously cloudy seas of soak-stained colour. These works project solid states of being as much as their evaporation into the unknown.
There are clear resonances with Sadler’s paintings and occasional traces (objects, photographs) of performative actions. But again, Sadler’s works cultivate a language of their own. At the centre is the question of imageability: how can cultural, historical, collective memory become an image without choosing the shortcut via iconic photography? How is space, colour, contour influenced by memory and cultural context? How can pictorial traditions be preserved and at the same time questioned, not least against the necessary dismantling of Western-dominated canon formations? His answers are infused with scholarly knowledge, but are clearly a painter’s: Jesus Marx Freud (2019) summons three dominant canonical figures, but as domesticated objects (Breuer chair, Marx bust, red hot barbed-wire cross), set into the eerie blue glowing of a modern space. Earl Roberts of Kandahar (2022) is a dreamlike, dark-night-of-the-soul scenario in which the Glaswegian statue of a British Victorian era general of that name and title is conjoined here with the neo-classicist entrance to Kairo’s Tahrir Square subway station; the Metro-like sign says “Roberts” in Arabic letters, while three figures outlined in glowing orange leave the viewer wondering whether they are praying, or falling over vomiting;thus the painting condenses British hubris from Empire to Brexit into one Kippenbergerian slapstick clash, while the nasty lies of former glory are exposed in the allegorical condensation of actual societal change.
Sometimes, during private gatherings as much as their semi-public “Fiction House” events, Sadler and Jakobsdóttir sing together; one favourite being their rendition of the Irish ballad The Homes of Donegal. Sadler’s grandfather on the mother’s side stems from that northernmost region, a man who had to commute, like so many Irish at the time, to the Glaswegian iron foundries. I tried to find a published rendition of that often-recorded song conveying the aching yearning of the lyrics about coming home to family, friends and pub acquaintances, before having to leave for the long journey again – but to me, all of them sounded kitschily sentimental, cheesy, or absurdly jovial in comparison to the minimalist beauty of Jakobsdóttir mezzo and Sadler’s tenor going through their meandering a cappela harmonies. It’s like a conversation starting with a monologue, but then with the other chiming in and taking over. And vice versa. Just like this exhibition.